Avatar
官方艺术家
Sean Tierney
演员, 编剧, 音乐家, 喜剧演员, 笔者
1,563,904 查看| 2,521  更新

Movie Review: Fog

I saw two films last week at the Hong Kong Asian Independent Film Festival.


Many of you know I am hardly Mr. Indie Film. I’m a tough customer for films that tend to be deliberate, pensive, and lack things like explosions and car chases.


As I told Fogdirector Kit Hui, I cannot watch Ingmar Bergman films, because I’ll have an aneurysm. She took this rather personally (odd, she doesn’t look Swedish), which almost made me feel bad, but I told her what I’ll tell you. *****I’m not saying Bergman is bad. He’s just bad for me.*


I have the attention span of an Australian hand grenade, and slow movies don’t do it for me. Wong Kar Wai bores me to tears.


But that’s just me. Obviously, lots of people love these kinds of films.


Better them than me, though.


The other thing many of you know is that I tend to be more than slightly… aspersive in my reviews.


I’ve been known to go after movies I dislike in much the same manner as Attila the Hun.


With hemorrhoids.


This is, according to some I have met, the best part of my reviews. Of course, the only people that say that are viewers.


Actors have, on occasion, expressed trepidation that one day they, or one of their films, may run afoul of my keyboard, so to speak.


Terence Yinhas mentioned this to me more than once, and with some of the films in his resume, I can see why he may be nervous.


When I headed to Elements last weekend to watch two independent films starring or involving people I would consider my friends, Iwas nervous.


Because A), I’m not generally an indie film fan and B), I didn’t want to have to say bad things about my friends.


So with these caveats, let’s get to the heart of the matter…


Fogwas the opening film of the HKAIFF 2010.


Kit Hui directed Terence Yin in this film about a man who has lost his memory and struggles to regain some understanding of his life and identity. He slowly pieces the puzzle back together, but we come to understand that even before his amnesia, the puzle was still missing some pieces.


Let me admit almost immediately that I liked the film.


Relax, Terence!


After all, Eugenia Yuan was in it.


Joman Chiang was in it, and she wearing a schoolgirl uniform.


Gloriana Wongwas in it too, and she ended up wearing even less.


While I can’t say I’m joking about these things contributing to my enjoyment of the film, let me say that there are many other and larger reasons why I enjoyed Fog.


The pacing of the film was what I call deliberate. Some might find it slow, but I didn’t. The story moved at its own pace, and it allowed time for reflection and thought, which the film not only invited but necessitated.


Big points for a film that encourages thoughtand has Cantonese dialogue. Nowhere near enough of that around here.


I enjoyed the matter-of-fact nature of much of the film; the degree of normalcy on display was very high compared to your average Cantonese language (i.e. local) film, and I appreciated that. It’s nice to see a story about (more or less) normal people doing normal things both good and bad.


I also enjoyed the very human nature of many of the characters; they were as flawed as they were virtuous.


It struck me as funny that a man who needs to literally rediscover who he is, and in so doing overcome mental trauma, spends almost all his time drunk, high, or both.


Any similarity between actor and character is purely incidental. Terence’s lawyers told me so.


Some of the dialogue seems, at times, a bit stilted, but that’s one of the problems you face in making movies. Movies are usually based in or driven by unusual people or circumstances, and within those boundaries, people often do or say things that are new to them.


What I mean to say is that the next time you find yourself in an unusual and uncomfortable setting (like talking to an unliked ex you run into), see how smooth and normalyou sound.


The ending of the film struck me as slightly jarring, coming rather unexpectedly. But on one hand, that’s often how indie films are; they don’t fit the mainstream mold and so they violate our expectations.


Upon further reflection, I realized that the film’s ending was jarring by necessity; the last scene sets up a narrative arc within which it would be difficult to find an egress. So if the end seemed abrupt, it was more because any ending point would be abrupt, not just this one.


I pleasantly suprised myself with Fog: I was afraid I wouldn’t like it, but I did. That’s a testament to the film, since I certainly haven’t changed as a viewer. It’s a good alternative to local cinema as well as a part of it. It’s thoughtful, interesting, and I hope more people get to see it.



As a festival film, let me just say it kicks the living dogsh*t out of last year’s opening film, Dead Slowly.

接近 7 年 前 0 赞s  5 评论s  0 shares

想要参加这个讨论

Photo 40915
i agree wit you
接近 7 年 ago | flag as spam
Mariejost 26 dsc00460
Maybe I'll get to see this one someday. Sounds a lot better than American Indie films these days. I made the mistake of watching one a few weeks back, and I still feel nasty all over, like I got into some poison ivy, every time I think about it. I'm glad your experience of a HK indie film was much better.
接近 7 年 ago | flag as spam
Photo 23627
Thanks for the kind words, Sean. Next time we meet, we won't discuss Bergman, but instead Tarkovsky :-)
接近 7 年 ago | flag as spam
Photo 28042
hahaha Tarkovsky. Why don't you just poke sticks in his eyes Kit. I LOVE Bergman compared to Tarkovsky. I didn't want to see any Bergman and then I saw couple of films where he exhibited some humor. He's not all black grim reapers Sean. I'm glad to see you liked this one Sean. You're lucky to have seen it. We'll wait here in the States for, hopefully, the DVD. How did the crowd like it?
接近 7 年 ago | flag as spam
Rottendoubt a4 patrick
*phew* ....
6 年多 ago | flag as spam

关于

If we don't support the movies that deserve it, we get the movies that we deserve.

阅读全文

语言
English,Cantonese
位置(城市,国家)以英文标示
Hong Kong
性别
Male
加入的时间
April 1, 2008

Sean Tierney的社交媒体