Official Artist
Kenji Lui
Director , Producer , Screenwriter
532,891 views| 228  Posts

Susan Boyle: Fact or fiction?

Yeah I know everybody has been talking about the Susan Boyle hype, I saw the video on youtube and it is certainly amazing, but I sometimes wonder if the world is as perfect as it appears.

I agree she can really sing, but I guess the critical factor for her success is not merely her talent, but the marketing strategy employed by the tv producers of the show. These guys really know how to play the game!

I wouldn't call it a fiction, indeed i see it as a successful packaging technique that fully utilized the power of the internet to achieve its goal..

I just read the article below and it sounds quite interesting. See if you agree:


Susan Boyle: Fact or fiction? 

By Bart Jackson, Vancouver Sun Whaddaya mean there's no Santa Claus?!It's worse than that. Internet sensation Susan Boyle, who garnered at least 30 million YouTube views with her Cinderella performance on Britain's Got Talent, is a player in a giant fraud.Or is she? She can surely sing, as evidenced by the tears that flooded the world as the plain Scottish lass sang the Les Miz hit I Dreamed a Dream.Suddenly, the 47-year-old self-proclaimed virgin became everybody's sweetheart, the kind that brings warmth in the middle of a frosty recession.And a show did talent curmudgeon Simon Cowell surely put on. Or was it crusty Cowell's put-on? If the Boyle tour de force was a publicity ploy, it rocked. From nowhere, she was everywhere: Oprah, Larry King, newscasts around the globe. Billions of hearts warmed.Then, out of New York City, among others, a giant wet blanket was thrown to cool the planet's ardour. Maureen Callahan in the New York Post noted that the Boyle event was too perfect: "A dowdy, 47-year-old virgin named Susan Boyle takes the stage, wearing her low heels and her Sunday best."The crowd laughs at her, and Boyle -- how devastating -- laughs along. She says she wants to be a professional singer; people laugh harder and louder. They point. It's grammar school and the Roman Colosseum combined. Simon Cowell -- panelist and show creator -- rolls his eyes. And then Susan Boyle sings."The same conspiracy theories rumbled online. Notes "Rick" on Yahoo:1) All of these shows have try-outs to filter out thousands of aspiring hacks before going on international television. Simon and the other judges were listening to her for the first time. This is not normal.2) The next sign to look for is the clumsy humpty-dumpty music played in the background at the beginning while she eats a doughnut. . . . The audience must have the perception of her being totally hopeless before she sings for maximum affect.3) The orchestra's music continues to play in the background even while the judges give their verdicts. As far as I know, this is the ONLY time this has ever happened in the history of this show. Simon's vote is saved for last and suspiciously timed out perfectly before the crescendo of the orchestra. This is exactly how a movie would plan the same effect to help jerk a few extra tears from the audience.Still, if it wasn't the spontaneous "reality" it pretended to be, the show was staged to perfection. And in these parlous times, give a fairy tale its due.

Video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RxPZh4AnWyk

over 12 years ago 0 likes  6 comments  0 shares
Photo 43244
there is no doubt about it. the editors did a fantastic job cutting the piece....inserting the audience making funny faces....laughing at her. you have to realize that those "inserts" may not even have occured at that time. The producers told a wonderful story...and I give them kudos for that. Yes, they continued to play the music. Yes, they zoomed in at the exact time to capture Simon's emotion. Yes, they sculpted that segment perfectly. But let's not let that take away from the actual performance itself. She has inspired millions...and like enigma said, there will always be someone in the background bitching and moaning about something. C'mon! Can't we just enjoy an experience just for the sake of entertainment. Did she move you? Did she inspire you? Did you enjoy it? To me, that's all that matters. Thanks Kenji for the article!
over 12 years ago
Johnnylu f9 johnnylu
i agree!
over 12 years ago
Mariejost 26 dsc00460
The important thing is that Susan Boyle has now achieved some notoriety from this program. It remains to be seen if she will really be given a chance to sing and make her living from her singing in the future. Could she be marketed as more than a novelty act? If she released an album, what material would it contain, who would buy it? Would that actually be enough for a career, or would it be a one-off? The British are most definitely different from American, Asians or other Europeans. How their publicity machine and music industry works is quirky to outsiders. Clearly someone is using Susan Boyle to their own ends, I just hope that she gains something meaningful and lasting from the whole experience. We can be pretty certain that she isn't going to be the next Madonna, Brittney or Beyonce. :-)
over 12 years ago


Don't forget your dream!

Learn More

Languages Spoken
english, cantonese, mandarin
Location (City, Country)
San francisco, United States
Member Since
May 14, 2007