Avatar
Official Artist
Kenji Lui
Director , Producer , Screenwriter
532,891 views| 228  Posts

Disappointed with Mainstream media | 可悲的主流媒體

Not sure if you guys know that there was a protest at CNN office in San Francisco yesterday. About 2000 people attended the protest, which lasted for more than three hours. The crowds were gathering outside CNN's office and packed the street corners. They were basically asking for an apology from CNN and the firing of the commentator Jack Cafferty.

I am not sure if this is good news material, but as a local news media, when you realize there are thousands of people gathering at the financial district of the city, don't you think you should at least send someone to take a look and see if it is worthwhile to do a story? I was there and somehow I didn't see any mainstream media there except for one tv station. There are chinese media and a lot of other people, but no mainstream media! Can you believe it?

There was a similar protest in LA last week and at least AP sent a photographer to take some pics, LA Times ran a story, and CNN itself also posted the news on its own website. What about the protest this time? Nothing in the local newnspaper San Francisco Chronicle, nothing in any of the mainstream TV stations... What does that mean????

I have been to some other smaller events before, even for a small protest with ten or hundred people, you always see at least a few TV stations or newspaper reporters doing coverage. Can you believe they DON'T KNOW the protest yesterday? Even if they didn't get the news in advance, do you think they would miss out the news when there're thousands of people in the street yelling? Why're they downplaying the incident?

Can you believe that in a city composed of 30% Asian, that's what we got??

西方傳媒輕視華人非一朝一夕﹐近日美國主流傳媒CNN主持人辱華一事﹐便再一次牽起風波。不少地方都有抗議活動 ﹐也有人製作網站展示歐美傳媒發放有關中國的誤導性新聞的證據。

以我個人經驗﹐這些對歐美傳媒的指控並不為過。好像日前在三藩市 ﹐數千華裔社群在當地的CNN總部集會抗議﹐聚集逾數小時﹐期間秩序良好﹐活動和平進行 ﹐可是當地主流媒體卻幾近無一作出即時報道。明顯地 ﹐先不論這是否具新聞價值﹐突然有數千人突然在鬧市街頭抗議 ﹐傳媒是否應至少派員到場採訪﹐才決定是否去做一篇新聞?

我恰巧當時在現場﹐滿目所見﹐除了一個主流電視台和一些中文媒體外 ﹐便沒有發現任何其他傳媒。及後上網查閱﹐在半天後也未見任何主流 傳媒對事件作出報告。以當地傳媒的效率和一貫做法 ﹐這都是極不尋常的處理。三藩市的亞裔人口達到三分之一 ﹐華裔聲音不少﹐仍然受到這種冷待﹐難怪美國主流媒體能夠一直肆意 輕視﹑歧視少數族裔﹐社會也無動於衷了 -因為在媒體的過濾性處理下﹐大眾根本無法了解真實的情況。

When you see such a crowd in the downtown area of the city, do you think it is at least worthwide to write a short story about it? On one of the mainstream media website, the only news about San Francisco after the event happens (the site is 24hrs updated) is "SF Park needs rennovation"...

about 16 years ago 0 likes  13 comments  0 shares
Kenjilui 15 blog profile
I think whether the protest is right or wrong, or what exactly it is about is not the major issue here, the fact that the media intentionally ignores the news is the real problem. A lot of people dunno this protest ever happens! The public deserves the right to know what happens, and it is the responbility of the media to report the fact, and let the readers decide what is right or wrong. But right now what the media is doing is just like:I am only telling you one side of the story and ask you to make a judgment.
almost 16 years ago
Mariejost 26 dsc00460
We are in the midst of the political season. Here in NC, if the news isn't of the Democratic primary which we hold here next Tuesday or of local politics (also figuring prominently in next Tuesday's election), then there isn't much chance it will get much, if any, news time. Same with print media. Because of the close Democratic primary race and continuing news there, added to the Olympic flap, the imploding US economy, oil prices, food prices, the war, etc., I'm surprised there was any coverage of this event, even in a local media outlet. I wish there was less coverage of the primary season, but most people wouldn't have it any other way in such a lively race. News organizations are in the business of getting ratings, selling papers, getting hits on their websites, so they are basically giving the public the news they figure it wants to hear. Hardly a free press, but this is the situation we have here in the US where the press competes on the open entertainment market right next to American Idol.
almost 16 years ago
Sean1
Agenda-setting. 'News' is chosen, not reported. Besides, the majority of Americans would probably be un-sympathetic (or so the producers believed). It may also be that Americans, having seen the crackdown in Tibet and the goon squad 'protecting' the torch*, didn't find it offensive or inaccurate. That said, I think Americans don't realize that they say 'China' meaning the CCP, but Chinese people hear 'China' the nation.
almost 16 years ago
Mariejost 26 dsc00460
I think you make a good point, whitebison66, when Americans think China, they think the Communist Party that runs the country. What do we know of the Chinese people? When Mao closed China back in the 50s, it was lost to view by the rest of the world. Then the Cultural Revolution (NOT good PR) happened, Vietnam war (where the Chinese were the bad guys, for sure, from the American public's point of view). China is this vast country that Americans know nothing about. I didn't realize until just recently how many officially recognized ethnic minorities there are in China (and that their treatment varies widely, not just talking Tibetans, here, either). Who knew that there are 8 or 9 officially recognized languages in China? Here in the West we see Beijing, Shanghai (if we are lucky) and a few historic sites like the tomb of the first Emperor. Maybe we have heard a snippet of Peking Opera (and it wasn't to our liking :-)) or saw Lang Lang perform Western classical music on television or DVD. For a country of over 1 billion people which covers a huge and quite varied landmass, and a people with 5,000 of cultural tradition, that is very little information for us to go on. If China wants to be better understood by the rest of the world, it needs to do more than give world-wide release to a few officially sanctioned bombastic films a year, films that mythologize its ancient and medieval history. Just hosting the Olympic Games is not going to give the rest of the world an in-depth look at China, its people, its history and its cultural traditions. John Woo's Red Cliff, a 2-hour Cliff Notes version of a 4-hour historical action blockbuster film, will not teach the West much about China and its history. China must bear some responsibilit for the fact that we know so little about it. Closing the country to Western film productions (who are then forced to shoot in Thailand instead of Shanghai) doesn't do much to improve this situation, either on a PR level or on a practical one. I think China must bear some responsibility for how ignorant the rest of the world is of the land, its people and its history. For far too long, the ruling party has controlled the image of China that has been presented to the rest of the world. That image has been of absolute obedience to authority, military might, intolerance of dissent, cultural uniformity (which is a myth), an economic miracle (which has grave social and environmental consequences that will be shown to the world during the Olympics, these problems are just too big to be hidden from 10s of thousands of journalists). There is plenty of blame to go around, and both China and the West bear responsibility for how little we know of China.
almost 16 years ago

About

Don't forget your dream!

Learn More

Languages Spoken
english, cantonese, mandarin
Location (City, Country)
San francisco, United States
Gender
Male
Member Since
May 14, 2007