! Choose language
選擇你的語言
close  
 語言 

Blog entries

  • Asians, the Generally Smarter Race

    Thursday, Jul 17, 2008 8:19AM / Standard Entry / Members only
    5 comments

    Here's an interesting article I read in the LA Times:

    Why do Asian students generally get higher marks than Latinos?
    http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-lincoln16-2008jul16,0,3712530.story
    In summary, the article examines the students of Lincoln High School who come from various parts of Boyle Heights, El Sereno and Chinatown.  Both the neighborhood and student body are about 15% Asian. And yet Asians make up 50% of students taking Advanced Placement classes. Lincoln Heights is mostly a working-class Mexican American area, but many are ethnic Chinese who fled Vietnam. 

    The difference isn't in class economics, 84% of the Asian and Latino families in the neighborhoods around Lincoln High have median annual household incomes below $50,000.  The difference is most Asian families value and stress the importance of education while more Mexicans value and stress getting paid work sooner than later. 



    I know the situation.  College was expected in my family.  I wasn't a straight A student, but I would've gotten worse if I didn't work it.  Then again, my district was tougher.  In the end, I earned a respectable academic performance.

    This is why I believe whenever a school, political candidate, or the government insists on pouring more money into schools to theoretically make students better, that theory is a bunch of crock.  It's mainly the student's responsibility to value their own education, study harder, and get good grades.  The parents are also to blame for not regulating.  Hard study ethic is all that's needed.  Sure, better teachers help but they can only do so much.  Buying new textbooks or shiny computers or paying teachers higher salaries is not going to make students smarter.

    All those other supposedly "dumber" minorities need to quit whining and get over their cultural laziness and study.  Once they do that, they too, can break through the invisible racial barrier and do the impossible like Carlos Garcia, the Mexican president of Lincoln High's Asian club, did.


    Carlos Garcia, second from right, is the ethnically confused President of Lincoln High's supposedly Asian club.

Entry comments (5)

  • Please login or sign up for FREE in order to add a comment.
  • mariejost
    Official artist
    posted on Monday, Aug 4, 2008 7:12AM [Report]
    Parent involvement with their children's academic studies has other consequences for schools, as well.  These parents, when there is a poorly qualified or lazy teacher, usually take action to have that teacher improve in the classroom, or be moved to another school.  Good teachers do matter.  Think of the horror stories of English teachers who were practically illiterate.  Why would we expect their students, especially if English was not their first language, to excel with such a teacher?  Parents who value education also value good teachers.
  • rottendoubt
    posted on Thursday, Jul 17, 2008 8:19PM [Report]
    it's hard for an asian to succeed in the us in entertainment...
  • jamesmar
    Official artist
    posted on Thursday, Jul 17, 2008 3:24PM
    Quite honestly, choosing to focus today's kid's studies between Math/Science and Arts/Design, I'd rather have Asian Americans be better in  brainy subjects like Math/Science/English.  

    Despite being an artist myself, I DO believe Asian Americans are much better off shooting for careers as doctors, lawyers, engineers, businessmen, architects, technology specialists, etc... instead of athletes or entertainers.  I only say that because I know how tough and unstable the arts route is.  The gamble odds are greater and many would end up penniless.  As a whole, Asians I think are better off succeeding in these more stable fields.  

    Eastern culture does has it's great entertainment/art/design people.  Japan especially seems to excel in it.  China, HK, South Korea aren't as influential but they're hardly invisible.  HK cinema was influential to Hollywood.  

    But the most important thing to stress is hard work ethic in whatever field kids choose (or get pushed into).  A college education or just valuing smarter thinking is very important.
  • JasonChau
    posted on Thursday, Jul 17, 2008 11:01AM [Report]
    There's something I want to say here now that you've mentioned it.
    Despite the great academic performance of Asian children in the West there is one area which I think a lot tends to miss out on. There is a danger for people of Asian descent studying too hard in academia to miss an understanding of the arts/design and creativity.

    If you notice in the West, a lot of emphasis is given to the children to be brought up in an environment understanding areas of art & design and culture, which helps increase their own creativity / freeform thinking. The fact you see so many new interesting designs/fashion/music/patents invented by the West is evidence of this policy in action. In the East, very little of this encouragement of studying arts is given to the children, even to the point about understanding one's own culture - as all emphasis is on how well they perform their mathematical tasks. But good maths people doesn't make good product designers or artists. And it is this which has caused such a paradigm between Eastern and Western culture.

    Why do you think HK at the moment has so many brands available? Most of them are not of HK/Chinese origin but are of Western origin. Why? It is because HK itself or rather the HK Chinese, sadly to say, hasn't developed enough of their own artistic/design culture to create an identity visible enough to be recognisable as Chinese. Most HK companies I know only 'borrow' what they know as best from the West - they don't invent things themselves. The same thing goes for the marketing. Just look at the TV adverts in HK for property developments/casinos and you see they all look more or less the same. The famous star with the Caucasians (usually pretty girls) and luxurious/lavish settings of yesteryear fit for a prince....all very cliched. The only HK Chinese company I think that has been visible and independent enough (and created a strong identity on the world stage) has been probably Hutchison (Li Ka Shing's company) with its Orange and 3 services. From the onset of the modern mobile phone (the ones created in the early 90s boom) Hutchison has been at the very forefront to provide such services, and its to be commended they have done this as a HK Chinese company operating in the West. Probably the greatest thing about Hutchison is that despite its origins.......is that you don't know its Chinese-owned. ;)
  • peachey
    posted on Thursday, Jul 17, 2008 10:45AM [Report]
    If you don't have the drive or fortitude, all those new computers and shiny textbooks aren't going to carry you to college. haha.

My blog More entries >

Stats

RSS feed

Shout box

Please first sign in or sign up for FREE to post to the Shout Box.

Archived shouts

Help support James Mar. Get registered to join their fan network, create your own profile, and connect with other friends and artists.