Avatar
Gary Lau
413,705 views| 208  Posts

Blog: Thursday, Dec 13

我認為我在寫這篇評論前﹐是需要時間平靜一下。就像電影<色﹐戒>一樣﹐我離開戲院的時候是很情緒化。感覺上﹐我還很低落。導演陳可辛拍得正好。這是一部由頭到尾的悲劇大製作。本片開始時看到龐青雲將軍(李連杰)在一大堆死屍下清醒。觀眾便跟著他走到一個村子裡然後他在一個女人面前暈低。他醒來便對那個女人哭訴他的兵已全軍覆沒。本片的片頭這樣子﹐你該想象得到了﹗片子裡除了三位結拜兄弟齊齊打之外﹐基乎是沒有開心事的。

下半待會再打。。

I had to calm down before writing this because this film left me pretty emotional.  Just like "Lust, Caution", it didn't leave me with a happy feeling.  In fact, it left me really depressed.  Director Peter Chan Hor-Sun made this movie just right.  An epic tragedy in huge proportions, from beginning to end.  The film starts off in a warzone where Pang Qing-Yun (Jet Li) wakes up in a huge land-filled pile of corpses.  We then followed him as he walks into a village where he falls unconscious in front of a woman.  He then wakes up to confess that his army of 1,600 soldiers have all died into battle after more than half of them had left the battlefield.  Well, you get the picture.  There is never really a happy moment except for the scenes where they are in the heat of the battle together.  

Despite the sad mood throughout the movie, this movie is, for the most part, excellent.  It is not your expected chop-socky kung fu flick at all.  In fact, Jet Li doesn't really have alot of one-on-one fights in the movie.  Even if there were, they weren't very long either.  Where this movie satisfies is the fact that director Peter Chan managed to fit in a good amount of dramatics in a war epic.  We actually see Jet Li and Andy Lau cry their hearts out.  We see Takeshi Kaneshiro and Xu Jinglei cry for a bit.  But Jet Li and Andy Lau's crying scenes were the most impressive display of acting range in this film.  Particularly with Jet Li because I doubt anyone has ever seen him cry in complete despair.  Emotional range in Jet Li was an absolute welcome sight especially for a film like this.  However, it's unfortunate that Xu Jinglei's scenes seemed rare and few.  Her character's affairs seemed more subtle than ever.  I would still recommend this movie.  This must be seen on the big screen!

almost 12 years ago 0 likes  7 comments  0 shares
Bleupluie 89 sono
agreeable...this movie must be seen on a big screen...though i haven't seen it, but an epic like this must have a huge screen for viewing pleasure...
almost 12 years ago
Photo 911
Wow......... i guess i'll have to wait until it on DVD
almost 12 years ago
Photo 35930
Lucky Gary!!!!!!! :D
almost 12 years ago
Photo 43083
Gary, xie xie! Can hardly wait to see it now, even though I don't like bloody battle scenes!
almost 12 years ago
Tinlunlau 06 tinlunlau
I loved the scene where Jet Li swung the &quot;gwan-dao&quot; around and chopped off the feet of like 6-7 soldiers. hahaha!
almost 12 years ago
Photo 23799
i'm not a big &quot;blood/ war&quot; fan... so i might pass on this one!
almost 12 years ago
Bleupluie 89 sono
FINALLY WATCHED IT!! on New Year's Day...what a bloody way to start off a new year... i enjoyed the battle in 舒城...the sight of real 重重包圍...震撼啊!
over 11 years ago

About

aka Gary Lau The contents in my blog may contain coarse language. Viewer discretion may be deemed redundant. Fellow PS3 players, fight me online! I ch

Learn More

Languages Spoken
english, cantonese, mandarin
Location (City, Country)
Toronto, Canada
Gender
male
Member Since
August 17, 2005

Gary Lau on Social Media