! Choose language
選擇你的語言
close  
 語言 

Announcement

  • Greetings!

    Current read: Green Mountain, White Cloud by Francois Cheng

Blog entries

  • Oh, look! Chinese people on "Supernanny."

    Monday, Jun 30, 2008 9:00PM / Standard Entry / TV / Members only
    11 comments


    Sometimes when I'm not reading or watching a movie in the evening, I might tune into the old standby - network programs on the telly.

    Those reality shows sure are taking up a lot of airtime. The stations are loading up their primetime schedule with some new reality shows - Wipeout!, I Survived a Japanese Gameshow to name two. Some are good, consistent and long-running such as The Amazing Race and Survivor. Some are entertaining - Hell's Kitchen catches my attention. Anyone remember Paradise Island? There have been only 2 seasons of that show. Big Brother was something I could never sit through.

    If family dynamics and the improvement of it is of any value to you, Supernanny is the show to watch. I don't follow the series for the fact that I actually find it a little stressful at times. Watching ill-behaved children and parents who don't have the skills to deal with them make me cringe and anxious.

    However, the part of the show where Jo Frost, the British supernanny, gives instruction on how to deal with getting the children and parents on the right track is engrossing and educational. Even though I'm lucky to not have those kinds of human terrors the show displays, there's always something to learn from each episode, patience and consistency being the constant, key behavīors.

    Something on the most recent episode made me go WTH. It  featured an interracial family of 5 with a Chinese dad and Caucasian mom.

    A father and daughter activity was introduced in an attempt to repair the non-existent relationship between the two. To have them get together (he travels for work weekly) and do something in a meaningful way. A dragon made out of orange and red balloons (and a paper dragon head) appears in their living room. This activity involves the father and daughter writing  their issues on a balloon and then popping the balloons. Sort of a way to symbolically annihilate these bad emotions so they can start fresh.

    Why did they have to use a dragon? Because the father was Chinese?? I've seen this activity before and the show had the family members just write on and then pop random balloons strewn in a bedroom.

    Another activity had the same daughter with the father writing Chinese calligraphy. WTH! The father didn't look like he even knew Chinese characters. I'm assuming this by his terrible strokes with his brush and his comment that he hopes "the ink doesn't stain," or something to that effect.

    They did have the father and daughter do fencing, which is a sport in which she's taking lessons. I could've gone "A-ha!" with that but I'll let that one by. Her pastime sure fits in with the Chinese stereotype though, doesn't it?  Maybe that's why the show incorporated fencing in the living room together.

    Anyhow, I felt they could've left the ethnic thing out of the show for this family. It's not like it's very common that Chinese families know or have an interest in Chinese calligraphy, dragon representations or sword-fighting.

    However, I'm fully aware that these colorful activities, especially the calligraphy, were totally new activities/angles in this show and something a regular Joe-Blow wouldn't usually get to see. 

    Half of me is thinking that ethnic flavor is....good....sometimes. The other half is thinking.....is it necessary?


    #

Entry comments (11)

  • Please login or sign up for FREE in order to add a comment.
  • peachey
    posted on Tuesday, Jul 1, 2008 9:56PM
    Those are some wacky questions, Ren. I don't think I've ever fielded those questions before. Doesn't mean they didn't have them in mind. haha.
  • Jaine
    posted on Tuesday, Jul 1, 2008 5:27PM [Report]
    interesting - striking the balance between racial stereotyping and promoting ethnic flavor.   I guess if it's not something the father or children are into then it is really just for show and token.
  • RenRen
    posted on Tuesday, Jul 1, 2008 12:54PM [Report]
    Gosh I hope nobody at work watches that show, next thing I need is for someone to ask me if i do Chinese calligraphy. As if having people ask me if I was related to Jacky Chan or do I know kung fu is not irritating enough.
  • JustKelly
    posted on Tuesday, Jul 1, 2008 11:28AM [Report]
    I've watched the show a few times.  Each time they manage to suprise me.  Some of these parents have NO control.  The kids cuss, hit...etc.  Where do they find these familiies?
  • butter
    posted on Tuesday, Jul 1, 2008 10:01AM [Report]
    I've never watched this show.  I think they make fun of it on The Soup.
  • Happybunny
    posted on Tuesday, Jul 1, 2008 6:06AM [Report]
    Sometimes when Mini-bunny is naughty I wish supernanny could knock on my door...but naaa honestly my girl isn't as bad as the little terrors on the show!!

    Anyway, I haven't seen this episode before. A bit annoying that they added the ethnic stuff when not really necessary only because the father is chinese. I don't do any of those things at home either.
  • unwoundclock
    posted on Tuesday, Jul 1, 2008 3:31AM [Report]
    did not see the whole episode.... i watched the parts where it seemed normal and not racist/stereotyping asians..

    the dragon and callig is unnecessary... but the fencing i think is ok..
  • janechu
    posted on Tuesday, Jul 1, 2008 12:02AM [Report]
    I haven't seen this show before but yea there are tons of reality shows nowadays... basically about anything. hahaa...

    but the chinese stereotype really doesn't sound necessary for the show... =(  *sigh*
  • Flagday
    posted on Monday, Jun 30, 2008 11:27PM [Report]
    I see your point, and it was just an attempt at making it interesting to the bulk of the primetime audience.  But I would hope that people of blended families would expose their kids to their ethnicity's cultures.  I really regret that in my baby boomer generation the objective was to be "American" so other than the foods and the church, I had NO exposure to my Italian or Polish sides.  In particular, my Noni and Dad spoke Italian, and purposely did not teach us the language except for a couple of songs.  Same with my Baba and Mom---they conversed and wouldn't teach us any of their language (more Lemko than Polish).  The focus was be a good American.  Sadly, so much is lost that way.
  • JoanneSanderson
    posted on Monday, Jun 30, 2008 10:19PM [Report]
    Jo Frost is pretty amazing with her strategies, I'm quite surprised at just how many parents do struggle to control their kids. I'm a bit surprised that they felt they needed to include ethnic stereotypical things in the show, if the family doesn't actually do that type of thing, especially seen as not every white family featured are stereotyped. Producers still have a long way to go in getting and seeing past stereotyping.
  • Dreamy
    posted on Monday, Jun 30, 2008 9:46PM [Report]
    Hmm i haven't seen it.......... maybe they want to bring out MORE of the ethnic flavor.......

My blog More entries >

Stats

  • I wish I could have a sunny disposition everyday, forever and ever.

    More

  • Gender: Female
  • Total visits: 128,990

RSS feed

Shout box

Please first sign in or sign up for FREE to post to the Shout Box.

Archived shouts

Join the alivenotdead.com community uniting musicians, filmmakers, and other artists with their fans